Soon our red snapper was delivered and I imagine we both must have looked surprised. Our fish was a fish! A whole fish! Head, tail, fins, and worst of all, eyes! There was a small slit exposing the meat.
I looked at her knowing that neither of us had encountered fish served whole like this and said “What do I do? I can’t eat this, he’s looking at me!”
“I know, but it cost twenty five dollars. You can’t just not eat it! Just try and ignore the looks.”
“No really. He is looking right at me!”
I moved my head left and then right and the whole time its eyes seemed to follow my movement!
“I think he can see me!”
“Don’t be stupid. You’re embarrassing me. Just pull it open like this.” She pulled hers apart like it was no big deal.
I started to very tentatively poke with my fork at the cut in his side. “His mouth just moved when I poked him! I’m sure he can feel that!”
“Don’t be an ass. It's dead. Eat it!” My girl took a slow breath and then tried 'the big boy approach'. She changed her voice to low and smooth with deliberate pauses between words like my mother used to. “Look, I know it’s a little gross, but you have too! This is how they do it in other countries. Pretend you’re in some exotic country trying new things … then later you can tell everybody how brave you were.” Then she smiled patiently at me and I knew that was my cue to try again.
I poked tentatively, trying not to embarrass her. I think he might have blinked. "Really, I can’t!”
“Fine, then you can just take it home and eat it there. Thanks for ruining my dinner!” she hissed like a evil serpent.
“I don’t want to take it home! Can’t we just let him go in the lobster tank? I’m sure once he’s back in the water he’ll be ok, and then I can order something else!”
After that I got the steely stare of death. She ate hers and occasionally looked up at me glaring. I sheepishly nibbled on crackers and eventually they wrapped up my fish to go. I had her take it home as I never wanted to see him again. I felt additionally bad knowing he was going to be very cold in her refrigerator. I briefly thought of suggesting she should wrap him in a towel for warmth, but decided I was in enough trouble already.
On the car ride back I was pretty quiet. She was mad, calling me juvenile, and I started to feel more like Mr. Fish with every block. Eventually, we got back to her house and she told me not to call her because I was immature and other unflattering characterizations.
I can’t help it if I am empathetic to the plight of a poor fish who sat there on my plate exposed, ready to be eaten. And besides, I’m pretty sure he could see me! Maybe they didn’t cook him enough and he was only wounded! How would you feel, lying there blinking at the people, hoping they don’t eat you!
No more trendy restaurants for me! No sir! I’m sticking to stuff that does not look like anything in particular, or stare at you. If you want to eat wounded fish, go right ahead, but you can count me out!